Choosing an ERP: criteria, process, and common mistakes

By Elisabeth BüschlerUpdated November 11, 2026

Choosing the wrong ERP can cost you years and six-figure sums. This guide walks you through the criteria, the selection process, and the most common mistakes, so you can find the system that actually fits your business.

Key takeaways

Define your requirements: Analyze your business processes and prioritize the features you actually need.

Check the criteria: Look at scalability, industry focus, integrations, costs, and support.

Test the system: Try ERP systems through demos or pilot projects before you decide.

Avoid common mistakes: Plan realistically, involve your team early, and vet the vendor thoroughly.

Choosing the right ERP system is one of the most important decisions a business can make if it wants to streamline its processes and grow over the long term. The right ERP system connects your workflows, makes your data easier to access, and boosts efficiency.

But the selection process is complex and needs a clear strategy. In this guide, we walk you through how to find the ideal ERP system for your needs, avoid common mistakes, and set your implementation up for success.

What does choosing an ERP system involve, and why does it matter? 

Choosing an ERP system is a critical process in which a business picks the right software to manage its operations. An ERP system brings departments and functions like finance, inventory management, production, and sales together on one central platform. The goal is to increase efficiency, streamline workflows, and make better decisions based on consistent data.

👉 Learn what an ERP is in our detailed guide

The choice matters because it has a long-term impact on your entire business. A well-chosen system can boost productivity, reduce errors, and support growth. The wrong system leads to inefficient processes and high costs, and in the worst case, it holds back your growth.

That's why it's essential to analyze your company's specific requirements carefully and choose an ERP system that's flexible, scalable, and future-proof. It's the only way to set your business up for sustainable growth.

Which criteria matter when choosing an ERP? 

When you choose an ERP system, you need to weigh several criteria to make sure the solution meets both your current and future needs. These eight factors play a key role in finding the right system:

  • Ease of use: The system should be intuitive and easy to use, so your team adopts it quickly and training takes less time.

  • Scalability: The ERP system has to grow with your business and support future requirements and expansion without friction.

  • Industry focus: An ERP system built for your industry offers tailored features that cover your specific needs better.

  • Costs: Look beyond the initial license or purchase price and factor in ongoing costs for maintenance, support, and add-ons.

  • Integration: The ERP system should integrate seamlessly with your existing systems and tools, such as your CRM or accounting software.

  • Flexibility and customization: Make sure the system can be adapted to support your specific business processes and requirements.

  • Support and updates: Reliable customer support and regular system updates are essential for long-term performance.

  • Security features: Look for a high level of security, especially if you process sensitive business data.

How does Xentral meet these eight criteria? 

Xentral is a cloud-native ERP built for growing merchants, manufacturers, and omnichannel businesses. More than 2,000 companies, from startups to mid-sized businesses, rely on the platform.

Our customers show what that looks like in practice. Sallys Shop handles 200,000 packages a year with Xentral and picks orders a third faster than before, a clear case for scalability and industry fit in food retail.

Schöner Kosmetik cut its logistics workload from 60 to 10 hours a week while increasing order volume by 25%, which shows how ease of use and integration directly affect costs.

RoofTech now closes its books in five minutes instead of four days. Managing Director Falk Magnus Strobel describes Xentral as “as intuitive as an iPhone.”

And VanDeBoard, a home and garden business, uses Xentral as an all-in-one solution to keep track of everything despite working with multiple suppliers and complex production processes.

Now you know what a good ERP needs to do 

Try Xentral free for 14 days and see for yourself whether it fits your requirements. No credit card required.

How does the ERP selection process work, step by step? 

1. Define your requirements

Start with a detailed analysis of your business processes to understand your specific requirements. Make a list of the features you need and rank them by priority. Take both your current challenges and your long-term goals into account. This clear definition is the foundation for choosing the right ERP system.

2. Research ERP vendors

Do thorough research to identify vendors that specialize in your industry. Check customer reviews, market reports, and the range of features each system offers. Also make sure the vendor offers scalable solutions that can grow with your business.

3. Test the software

Test shortlisted ERP systems through demos or pilot projects. Check usability, performance, and how well each system fits your existing processes. Get feedback from the people who will use the system every day to make sure it meets their needs.

4. Make your decision

Evaluate the systems you tested against criteria like cost, functionality, flexibility, and support. Factor in your team's feedback so you know they'll get on board. Make an informed decision that covers both your current and future needs.

5. Plan the implementation

Create a detailed implementation plan that covers integrating the ERP system into your existing processes, migrating your data, and training your team. Define clear responsibilities and a timeline to ensure a smooth rollout.

Which mistakes should you avoid when choosing an ERP? 

Choosing an ERP system is a complex process where careful planning and analysis are critical. Even so, mistakes happen often, and they can be expensive. To avoid them, it helps to know the typical pitfalls and actively steer clear of them. These are the most common mistakes when choosing an ERP:

  • Unclear requirements: Missing or incomplete analysis of your business processes and needs often leads to the wrong choice.

  • Focusing on price instead of value: Deciding on cost alone can leave you without key features or with a system that can't scale.

  • Overlooking ease of use: Complex, hard-to-use systems can seriously hurt adoption across your team.

  • Not planning for growth: A system that doesn't scale quickly hits its limits as your business grows.

  • Ignoring integration options: An ERP system that can't connect to your existing tools and systems creates extra work and costs.

  • Unrealistic time and resource planning: An overly optimistic project plan can lead to delays and extra effort.

  • Not vetting the vendor enough: Skipping research into a vendor's reliability, support, and experience can cause problems down the road.

  • Skipping a proper test phase: Without a thorough test phase before the final decision, you risk unpleasant surprises during implementation.

Want to avoid these mistakes? 

A consultation with our team helps you make the right choice. Free and with no obligation.

Choosing an ERP system is a decision for the future as much as for today. In an increasingly digital world, the demands on ERP solutions keep changing. In 2026, cloud ERP gives businesses more flexibility and scalability by delivering software from the cloud that you can access anytime, anywhere.

Artificial intelligence (AI) is also being built into ERP systems to enable automated processes, data-driven decisions, and predictive analytics. Xentral is already a step ahead here. With Agent Hub, Orchestrator, and human-in-the-loop controls, AI agents handle routine tasks like posting invoices or processing returns on their own, in compliance with the GDPR and with full control. Mobile apps also make it easier to access key business data on the go, which boosts productivity.

On top of that, integration with other systems is becoming more important to keep information flowing smoothly and help different parts of the business work together efficiently. These trends don't just shape which ERP system you choose. They also set the direction your business will take in the years ahead.

Looking for an ERP that helps you take off? See how the right ERP system helps you work more efficiently and grow. Get started with Xentral and book a free consultation to see our software in action.

Frequently asked questions 

14 days for free

Automate all your processes in Xentral ERP

Elisabeth Büschler
Elisabeth Büschler
She is passionate about innovative brands and content - which is why Xentral, with its more than 1,700 start-ups and SMEs, is the perfect place for her. Her motivation is to take the Xentral community to the next level with helpful content.
👉 More about Elisabeth

Learn more